ART OF SOUND
REVIEWS AND CUSTOMER FEEDBACK
Full review of the Tycus subwoofer from the Stereo Times.
"The Art of Sound Tycus Subwoofer
A recipe for mid-priced excellent."
Clement Perry
15 July 2003
" … I promise to love, cherish,
honor and respect you, from this day forward, for better, for worse, in joy and
in sorrow, in sickness and in health, for as long as we both shall live."
This is the premise of the perfect "made in
heaven" marriage, no doubt about it. Another great coupling, thanks to the
popularity of hi-fi home theater, is that of subwoofers and home theater. Today,
subs and home theater systems go together like peanut butter and jelly, bacon
and eggs, Bubba and Gump, children and Scooby-Doo. No matter the price, size,
sophistication, or lack thereof, subwoofers have turned into a
"must-have" for home theater enthusiasts. Unfortunately, recent trends
reveal that quantity, more times than not, outweighs quality. The prerequisite
for the ultimate subwoofer appears to be, the bigger the box-and what's in
it-the better. Problem is, these sonic BOOM boxes are often too big and slow to
keep up with the music's pace, and have had the most difficult time finding
their way into to the rarefied air of a true two-channel audiophile rig. Every
movie has an ending, and when the projector's turned off, the screen gets
pulled, and those "extra" channels are quieted. In most cases, you
turn off that sub too, don't you?
If you can recall an article written in Stereophile some years back, featuring
the buff model Fabio, sporting Krell Reference Standard amps and the huge
four-piece Genesis loudspeakers, it will certainly bring to mind why the trend
continues. Here was a state-of-the-art setup that boasted thousands of watts
gushing through perhaps a dozen twelve-inch woofers that, much to my amazement,
made some listeners literally sick to their stomachs! Now don't get me wrong,
very few things can massage the male ego as well as a couple of well placed
subwoofers, while watching great war flicks like Saving Private Ryan, U-571,
or Black Hawk Down, on a big screen. I would love to pass a couple of 17Hz
notes through some of my boys and watch 'em run and kneel before that porcelain
altar.
Few companies have accomplished the rare task of handling both the dynamic
demands of bass-heavy movies and the delicacy of a cello's string. REL Acoustics
has, and so has Talon Audio. Wilson's latest sub impressed the heck out of me at
CES 2003. Unfortunately, none of these are what most of us would qualify as
affordable. Needless to say, I was quite delighted to find the subject of this
review, the $1803.00 Art of Sound Tycus subwoofer, deserving of this
distinction.
Head honcho and chief designer Dave Craig believes that building subwoofers for
movies and sound is " … easy to master if done correctly." "I
know the inner workings and I've been involved in and around audio, in one form
or another, for well over twenty-years," he said. Armed with good audio
instincts, a knack for building things and a degree in mechanical engineering,
Craig set out to build the best subwoofer, using the best design available. In
building the Tycus, Craig uses dual 10" Peerless woofers: one active, one
passive. A specially designed, built-in amplifier, which boasts high-grade
toroidal transformers and discrete Mosfet output devices, provides a very
realistic 300 watts output and comes standard. There are a variety of inputs,
including a "speakon" connector which allows a secure connection from
the main amplifier outputs, for the high-level input, to the subwoofer panel amp
(a popular pro sound method that is used in Europe and is somewhat slow in
catching on here in the states. REL uses this connector). Phase, crossover
setting (from 30 to 150 Hz), balanced (!) and RCA inputs, high and low-crossover
controls complete the Tycus' physical layout and make this quite a versatile and
well thought-out design.
It's obvious that Craig
takes great pride in designing Art of Sound's products, and the Tycus is no
exception. Physically, the Tycus appears well-made and attractive, especially
when compared to most of the competition's standard, boring,
matte-black-only-approach. My review sample arrived in beautiful dark grain
Mahogany-a near perfect match, in terms of wood finish, to my custom-built
Zoethecus equipment rack. In terms of WAF appeal [Wife Acceptance Factor], the
Tycus is an easy choice if you're planning to blend it into a room's décor.
A good portion of my listening impressions were done in a home theater
environment, using both a Sampo 34" 16:9 monitor, as well as the new and
exciting 46W1 46" Plasma from newcomer BenQ (pronounced Ben-Q). Musical
Fidelity's HTP pre/processor, five-channel amplifier as well as their DVD player
were used throughout the review process. Home theater loudspeakers were the BMB
Custom monitors, while two-channel-only loudspeakers started with the tiny
Xavian Mia, and the handsomely elegant German ELAC 310i JET mini-monitors. The
larger Rosinante Dulcinea monitor, a long-standing reference for what monitors
could-and should-do, and the only American loudspeaker in the bunch, paired with
the Tycus and sounded gorgeous. Full-range loudspeakers were the Tanagra
Signatures ($6500) from the new French manufacturer Apertura, and the $10,000,
Isophon Europa, a transducer I've really grown to love for its amazing clarity
and seductive midrange. At the end of these sessions, one thing stood quite
clear: no matter the price, setup or configuration, a subwoofer of the Tycus'
asking price can enhance not just the performance of a home theater setup, but
can take various monitors and floor-standers to the next level.
"Spectacular gun battles!" says Richard Roeper, of Ebert and Roeper
fame for the underground sensation DVD, Equilibrium. This movie stars Christian
Bale (American Psycho), Emily Watson (Breaking the Waves) and Taye
Diggs (Brown Sugar) in a film whose storyline mimics The Matrix,
albeit with a sloppier plot. Futuristic and a bit slow throughout, with a
somewhat kooky, thought-provoking theme, the battle scenes are well worth the
price of admission, and should make you glad you bought this sleeper. The Tycus
also thanked me for this DVD's great surround effects: its low-end energy was
convincingly real throughout and never got out of hand during the heavy fight
scenes. Never did the Tycus lose its excellent ability to remain invisible. With
the volume only modestly loud, an extraordinary sense of balance overtook the
BMB speaker system, creating not just greater low-energy information, but
providing a sense of realism to this action-packed flick, as well as enhancing
the authenticity of the movie's overall mix. The ability for a subwoofer at this
price to blend so effectively with the rest of the system, creating a near
seamless match with entirely different loudspeakers, was quite impressive to say
the least.
Another great action DVD and torture test for any subwoofer is the savvy James
Bond film, Die Another Day. Of course, what makes this movie such an
eye-catcher is sultry spy Halle Berry's hip-huggin', slo-mo Cuban beach shot (a
female Bond in full bandwidth. I knew the Tycus was working, but this scene had
all the boys woofin'!). Few movies offer as much of a stress test as a good Bond
flick, and this, his latest, doesn't disappoint. The scene where Bond attempts
to escape via a hovercraft, with a militia in hot pursuit, took the Tycus on a
dynamic roller coaster ride that it seemed to enjoy more than we did. With the
Tycus disengaged, and driving the BMB's full-range, there is an obvious
difference to this movie's overall dynamics and impact. Cannon blasts,
explosions, engines revving, planes flying overhead, were diminished greatly in
what I would describe as the "real-life" quotient. It appears that
though many loudspeakers can handle a movie in full-range mode, no matter the
driver compliment, there seems to be an advantage to using a dedicated sub.
Movies simply sound better with a sub rather than without, irrespective of the
setting on your surround sound processor. In this case, score two points for the
Tycus!
Switching to music only for example, while listening to Parker's Mood
[Verve 314527907-2], the music of Charlie Parker by the Steven Scott Trio,
featuring Roy Hargrove and Christian McBride, really shows how brilliant Parker
was, and in our case, how slow a sub's start/stop time can be. Pick your poison,
any track from this wonderfully recorded CD will do. I personally like them all,
but tracks one through six are stupendous recordings, as bassist Christian
McBride really shines in his pursuit to keep up with the wizardry of trumpeter
and bandleader, Roy Hargrove. In doing so, he excites his instrument in a way
that is quite exquisite. Because there are no drums on this track, McBride
serves as a human metronome, keeping time, rhythm, pace and harmony so perfectly
well, that he unleashes all the reasons why he's such a great and sought-after
bassist. This also makes this CD an audio reviewer's dream because of its
ability to determine the effectiveness of speed and musicality in low-end
transducers like subwoofers. The Tycus simply fleshes out more of McBride's
instrument, going octaves lower, while keeping up with the BMB's note for note,
with a cohesiveness that sounded alarmingly smooth, while remaining undetectable
in its location. It simply disappeared while making the BMB's perform like
full-range loudspeakers.
Another extremely good CD to hit only recently is the Brazillian Entre Amigos
featuring Rosa Passos and Ron Carter [Chesky JD247]. This hauntingly
sophisticated duo brings memories of Antonio Carlos Jobim right up to the
surface, with the remake of Desafinado. If you've never heard of Rosa
Passos then this disc will allow you to never forget her. Ditto Ron Carter, the
bassist who exemplifies what a jazz bassist is all about. Combine these two
ingredients with the Chesky brothers and you've got yourself an instant classic.
Audiophile-wise, this disc is magnificent for determining what your system is
and isn't doing. No matter the track, the Xavian, as well as the Elac 350's,
paired with the Tycus, took the music further in the areas of dynamics and
full-range qualities. With the Tycus set at a reasonable 50 Hz, the sound of the
Xavian was very impressive. The Elac didn't hesitate to show off the amazing
ribbon clarity their tweeter's well known for. In both instances, each speaker
sounded much bigger than they had any right to. It's no mystery to many
of us here what the real advantages of fast and accurate subwoofers can be,
after spending many months with the Talon Roc 12. The Tycus serves as a
reminder-at half the price.
The Tycus excelled in all areas of importance, particularly speed and power,
though it does give up some location only when pushed too hard. When played
within its boundaries, the Tycus played the lower notes (50 Hz and below) of
McBride's bass right along with the Elac 350 mini's, Rosinante Dulcinea's, as
well as the tiny Xavian Mia's with absolute aplomb.
The Tycus allowed the full-range Isophon's, employing dual 9" woofers of
their own, to produce an even bigger sound. The Tycus did not exaggerate
the low-end nor did it give the appearance of being "placed" into the
system. It blended in only to solidify the bass, much like the Talon Roc does,
without overstating it. The Tanagra Signature, on the other hand, due to its
warm overall tonal balance, didn't seem to appreciate the Tycus as much as the
other, more neutral sounding Isophon's did. The Tanagra is another one of those
midrangy types that exemplifies male and female voices. That said, it also seems
to really possess bass that may appear too plump in some applications. Not a bad
thing when you don't have a sub like the Tycus around to help out. I would pass
on purchasing the Tycus with a loudspeaker of the Tanagra Signature's
characteristics. Otherwise, you can't go wrong with this extremely flexible and
incredibly priced subwoofer.
This high-level playback quality is what all subwoofers should perform at. But
more often than not, most low to mid-price subs miss the mark. Fewer are ever
judged so extensively. The Tycus actually enjoyed being compared to the mighty
Talon Roc 12. The Roc will play louder and go deeper, but at double the price-it
damn well better be. The Tycus, thanks largely to its speed, kept up in the area
of seamlessly blending itself into the fabric of whatever loudspeaker it was
coupled with. The Tycus also plays very quiet. Enough to virtually hide its
identity no matter the placement. And lastly, the look and build of the Tycus is
attractive enough to make it an easy choice in aesthetically demanding
environments. Highly recommended.
Art of Sound would like to thank Stereo Times for such a glowing review of our product!
____________________________________________________________________________
Customer Feedback
____________________________________________________________________________
Comments regarding the Maximus subwoofer.
(email of 11/22/02)
I'm
still fiddling with the settings on both subs; however, my initial impression is
that your sub (maximus) plays louder, has more "slam" factor and is as
musical as the REL (Storm III).
I'm very pleased with your product. I have your sub connected to the front mains
using the speakon connection and the REL to the rears. Both subs are connected
to the LFE output via a splitter.
Buddy
(email of 8/7/02)
Comments regarding the Tycus subwoofer.
(email of 01/10/03)
Dave,
I received and hooked up the sub yesterday. Everything is fine. I
will
need to do some fine tuning and I would imagine it will take some time to
break in. I don't have my two channel pre-amp yet so I won't be able to
appreciate it as much with a sound processor but I can already hear
improvements over my HSU VTF-2 (Class A rating in Stereophile Guide to Home
Theater. Reviewer's Choice Award 2000 in Sound & Vision.).
Thanks,
Jim
(email of 01/06/03)
The
subwoofer sounds great. In fact you don't even know its there. It
blends in terrifically
with my speakers. The music is the most important
to me anyway, and the movies sound good the way I have it set up now. I am
very pleased with my purchase.
Mark
(email of 11/28/02)
Dave,
Your sub arrived safely and I must admit looks more beautiful than on your
website (isn't that always the case?). The sound is also quite impressive on the
DVD Men in Black II. Don't know if you enjoy a good movie on DVD but this is
certainly one to try for nice and deep low end extension. Haven't had much time
to do anything else besides hook it up and watch this movie with some friends
and family last night. So far, so good. I can also see from a quality standpoint
this sub's much more attractive both in build as well as looks than the Sunfire
Signature it's replacing.
See
full
review of the Tycus below or at www.stereotimes.com
Happy Thanksgiving,
Clement
Perry
Publisher
The
Stereo Times
The Complete Audiophile Internet Magazine
http://stereotimes.com/
201/386-9416
917/414-3313
Comments regarding the "Cynergy" subwoofer (replaced by the Tycus).
(email of 1/21/02)
Hi
Dave.
You can give my phone no. to anyone you wish. I would highly recommend your
product.
English is not easy for me. if you knew Hebrew I could have send you link to a
very
long excellent review in Hebrew that I wrote about the cynergy in an
audiophile Israeli internet forum ( something like the Audio Asylum).
Best regards (-:
Meni
<toren1@optonline.net>
_________________________________________________________________________
Comments regarding custom subwoofer built using 21"Cabasse woofer.
(email of 11/19/01)
Dave,
The
sub continues to break in nicely. I
really wound them up today to listen to Talvin Singh, the CD I sent to you, to
demonstrate the range to my son. He
was mightily impressed, and so was I. The
speed of the sub has been a eye-opener, and I have found nothing so far that can
confuse or obscure the purity, proportionality and power of the bass.
Those “3 P’s” have been coming dramatically in to focus as the unit
“loosens” up, and on a well-recorded CD are a revelation.
I must say that Kevin in England was the only person I trusted to deal
with component matching until we did our business with you, but I don’t
believe that Kevin could have manufactured me as good a match with the sub…..
and that Dave is a real compliment
to your work given Kevin’s dazzling award-winning speaker designs.
That Cabasse driver was a brilliant choice, and if you talk to the
company again, you can tell them that I am just “gob-smacked” at its
performance and “amplitude.”
_________________________________________________________________________
(email from August 26, 2001)
The
subs are beautiful and work great. W/O the benefit of breaking in, the
bass seems to be a bit tighter and faster than the original Jazzmon. I'll
keep you posted as time goes by, as I didn't have the time to put it through
its paces yesterday, but will today. So far, I would say it integrates even
better with the Beauhorns, than the original.
I'm
sure you have a winner here for the music lover. You just have to get
the word out.
Frank
Goldfarb
FIG